Prawo Zamówień Publicznych

no. 4/2021

Issues with non-price criteria when evaluating offers Commentary to the judgments of the District Court in Warsaw of 23 June 2021. (XXIII Zs 35/21) and of 18 December 2020. (XXIII Ga 1350/20)

Andrzela Gawrońska-Baran
doktor nauk prawnych, ekspert z prawa zamówień publicznych, radca prawny, Nr ORCID: 0000-0002-3695-8769.
Abstract

In these judgments, the District Court presented an interpretation that actually narrowed the catalogue of possible offer evaluation criteria. Through its position, by disregarding the fact that the Public Procurement Law explicitly provides for quality criteria of evaluating offers that are verifiable on the basis of the declaration contained in the offer, the court creates a certain view of the legislator’s irrationality. The court’s interpretation, which is difficult to agree with, may result in a step backwards, as it may result in limiting the evaluation of offers to price criteria, while the legislature has been consistently obliging contracting authorities for years to use non-price criteria for the evaluation of offers.