Studia Prawa Prywatnego

no. 3/2024

Transactions on the European art market from the viewpoint of consumer protection in the European Union. The problem of effectiveness of this protection

DOI: 10.32027/SPP.24.3-4.4
Paula Mroczkowska-Król
Szkoła Doktorska Uniwersytetu Kardynała Stefana Wyszyńskiego w Warszawie
Abstract

This article aims to characterise transactions taking place in the European art market from the perspective of consumer protection in the European Union. It also attempts to answer the question of whether consumers engaging in transactions involving works of art in the European market are adequately protected by the EU legislator and what means of protection they are entitled to under national law, including when EU legislation proves insufficient.
The text attempts to define the concept of ‘works of art’ on the basis of European Union legislation. It refers to the system of consumer protection in the European Union, before moving on to specific issues such as the conformity of a work of art with the contract, the withdrawal from a contract for the sale of a work of art concluded at a public auction or at fairs and exhibitions, respectively. It also discusses the effects of concluding a contract for the sale of a work of art under the influence of a mistake and refers to the consumer’s declaration to waive the contract. The indicated institutions are discussed based on examples from the jurisprudence of Polish and Frenchcourts as well as the Court of Justice of the European Union.
The last part of the text enumerates the main problems of the European art market from the perspective of consumers’ rights and contains a postulate to emphasise the distinctiveness of this market in European legislation in order to protect the rights of this group of buyers more comprehensively.

Keywords
work of art, European Union, art market, consumers’ rights
Literature
T. Czech, Prawa konsumenta. Komentarz, Warszawa 2017;
K. Dąbrowski, Ochrona praw konsumenta w Polsce - głos w dyskusji, Zeszyty Naukowe WSEI, 2016, Nr 1(6);
M. Drela, Cywilnoprawne konsekwencje niewykonania lub wadliwego wykonania umowy sprzedaży dzieła sztuki przez sprzedawcę, w: Rynek sztuki. Aspekty prawne (red. W. Kowalski, K. Zalasińska), Warszawa 2011;
M. Ganczar, E. Sługocka-Krupa, Ochrona konsumentów i jej współczesne wyzwania, Lublin 2014;
Ochrona konsumenta w prawie polskim i Unii Europejskiej (red. M. Królikowska-Olczak, B. Pachuca-Smulska), Warszawa 2013;
Wyzwania dla prawa konsumenckiego w wymiarze globalnym, regionalnym i lokalnym (red. M. Namysłowska, K. Podgórski, E. Sługocka-Krup), Warszawa 2022.