Monitor Prawniczy

no. 12/2019

Presumption of injury in the criminal procedure in Poland

DOI: 10.32027/MOP.19.12.3
Błażej Boch
Autor jest doktorantem w Katedrze Postępowania Karnego WPAiE Uniwersytetu Wrocławskiego oraz aplikantem prokuratorskim KSSiP.
Abstract

In the article, the author attempts to analyse the status of the victim (injured party) in the Polish criminal procedure. The analysis is based on presentation of the so-called presumption of injury. Therefore, it has been emphasized that granting of a victim status under the criminal procedure results from adoption of a presumption, supported by substantiated factual evidence. The subject is analysed in comparison with the presumption of innocence. When the trial ends with a conviction, the presumption of innocence falls, whereas the presumption of injury holds, which means that a person’s status as a victim is confirmed, whereas in case of an acquittal the presumption of innocence falls, which means that such a person should lose such status. The author analyses specific issues, e.g. the possibility of filing cassation by the victom in case of a conviction. The analysis leads to formulating critical conclusions and putting forth de lege ferenda proposals.